Discarded

My office is on the first floor of the building that contains the college library, which takes up the entire upper floor. The building is slated for renovation starting after Christmas, meaning the whole building will be gutted and designed. The architectural drawings we’ve been shown are not recognizable as the same building. I hope it will be an improvement.

In the meantime, we’re slowly emptying our offices. I have four full-size bookcases full of books that I’m trying to evacuate a few diaper boxes at a time. Upstairs, the library is culling its stock.

Last week they sent out an itemized list of books they’d withdrawn from circulation and made available free to whomever was willing to come get them. I put in a request for several and got these four:

  • Hitler, by Werner Maser, trans. by Peter and Betty Ross

  • Edmund Burke: A Historical Study, by John Morley

  • Robespierre: A Study and Richelieu: A Study, by Hilaire Belloc

I picked up Maser because I recalled him as one of the (many) subjects of the late John Lukacs’s The Hitler of History, which I wrote a bit about (here and here) when I was reading it five years ago. I looked Maser up in Lukacs again: indefatigable archival researcher who decisively put paid to several debated topics in the historiography but was apt to overrate his achievements, even a bit cranky. One thinks of Cicero boasting of saving the Republic. I’m glad to have a copy, though some past cad checked the book out and underlined a lot of passages throughout. I hope he got a good grade on his paper.

I was most excited about the two studies by Belloc. As much as I love Chesterton, I’ve read very little of Belloc and mostly know him by reputation. If he’s as pugnacious as people say, his perspective—hardcore traditionalist and reactionary (all adjectives meant as compliments)—on Robespierre should be bracing and enjoyable. These are nicely bound, too. “Beautifully got up,” as an older Brit might say. Robespierre includes the most flattering portrait I’ve ever seen of the Jacobin weasel, still protected by the original sheet of tissue guard.

The Burke book made me a bit melancholy. It’s a reprint of John Morley’s 1867 monograph. A preface clarifies that the publisher sought and obtained the rights to reprint the book because Morley’s perspective on Burke would be helpful, worthy to keep in print. Internet Archive has editions of the same work from 1888, 1893, and 1913. Morley died in 1923 and this reprint appeared a year later. It’s 102 years old. I shudder to think what would have been done with it if I hadn’t picked it up.

All four of them are blazoned all over with DISCARDED stamps, but still have most of their old-school library detritus: index cards, records of check-in and check-out pasted into the back flyleaf. I love this paraphernalia, and yet even this provokes melancholy. One of the Belloc volumes was last checked out when I was four months old. Now the library has decided it doesn’t need any of them.

It’s unclear to me what form the college library will take when it’s reconstituted in the refurbished building—though real libraries are still being built, more and more “libraries” are now “media centers” with vanishingly small numbers of actual books—but the volume of discards is alarming. (None of this should be construed as blaming the college’s excellent library staff; they’re responding to top-down and cultural changes just like we are.) I hope it’s just a fraction of the overall collection, but looking through the shelves of withdrawn and free-to-a-good-home books I saw a lot of good stuff, books I’d love to have on hand for future generations of students writing a paper, just browsing, or trying to find out more about something that piqued their interest in one of my classes.

But who am I kidding? I’ve been upstairs. The library is silent as the grave most of the time, and not out of the traditional respect. Extra-library enticements have failed: inviting stacks of boardgames and current magazines sit undisturbed, couches arranged for conversation sit empty. Even the study carrels are vacant. We all know where students go for study and research now, if they study and research at all.

It’s not the books so much that have been discarded, but the entire intellectual ecosystem. My copy of Morley’s Burke is freshly printed by comparison with the tradition the library represents. An institution that traces its lineage back to the collegium and the Benedictine scriptorium—if not yet further back to Roman archives and the great collection at Alexandria—is dying. These four are the fragments I have shored against my ruins.

I’ve never so hoped to be wrong.

On bookmarks

Someone on Substack recently posted an open question about bookmarks—why and how do we use them? When? What do we use for bookmarks? It was a neat bit of engagement farming that I avoided replying to, but I have spent a lot of time thinking about bookmarks and wanted to jot a few notes about mine for this commonplace book.

The history: I used to pride myself on not needing bookmarks. I could pick up a book I was reading and find my place right away, down to the word in the paragraph where I’d left off. (A mostly idle boast: I pathologically avoid stopping mid-anything, preferring not to stop until I’ve at least finished a paragraph—preferably a chapter.) I maintained this attitude through high school and into college, but at some point during undergrad I started marking my place more often. I suspect this was out of convenience and because of the number of books I was reading at any given time, not to mention the number of books I’d be using to research a paper.

Since then I’ve habitually used bookmarks. Found them indispensable, really.

The what: It started with receipts from Barnes & Noble, Waldenbooks, the campus bookstore—wherever I’d bought a book. I still enjoy running across these, as they record a long-ago selection I’ve forgotten. Sometimes I would use an unrelated receipt, something within grabbing distance. I’ve found the receipts for DVDs purchased at Walmart twenty years ago inside old books. Sometimes I’d buy an actual bookmark, usually something Lord of the Rings-related with a tassel and some kind of gewgaw like a fake One Ring dangling from it. I never got used to these, as the tassel tended to get in the way, and ended up throwing most of the tassels away. The Rings passed out of all knowledge.

I still occasionally use a receipt, but I now have a large stock of purpose-made bookmarks. An literal drawer-full of them.

Some are gifts or souvenirs. I have a prized one from the Mark Twain House in Connecticut, which Sarah and I visited when we were dating, so the bookmark itself signifies more than it might seem. Another is from Librairie Galignani on the Rue de Rivoli in Paris, the oldest English-language bookshop on the Continent. I keep this one inside the Penguin Classics edition of A Tale of Two Cities I bought there.

A few are from old magazines, some I didn’t even subscribe to but which rightly thought a free bookmark would be a good promo. I have a few novelty bookmarks, too, like an all-metal gilt-edged Robert E Lee with a crimson tassel. I don’t think I’ve ever put it in a book.

My favorite right now was a Father’s Day gift from my wife this year: a cartoon T-rex skeleton on rugged transparent plastic. Cheers me up just to look at it.

But a lot—a big, colorful majority in my nightstand drawer—are from bookstores. Mr K’s Used Books has free bookmarks by the register, and I usually grab one when I check out. A few have lasted for years, stained, faded, and soft and fibrous at the edges.

I also have a promo bookmark or two for my own books from Local Author Expos past, a Lost-themed promo for a friend’s senior art show twenty years ago, a laminated birth announcement for my eldest son that ran in my hometown newspaper and, from the same paper, a laminated obituary for my grandmother. I almost never use those two.

Two significant categories are bookmarks drawn and colored by my kids and bookmarks from defunct bookstores: Bentley’s Bookshop in Greenville, The Book Mark in St Simons, and Prater’s Main Steet Books in my hometown. I prize these because they are personal in some way. The shuttered stores, even the ones I didn’t spend that much time in, like Bank Square Books in Mystic, Connecticut, which I visited twice years and years ago, are parts of the past that I can’t go back to.

The bookmarks from my kids mean even more, naturally. My daughter made bookmarks for everyone she knew a few years ago. Those she gave me are both adorable (one shows a caterpillar reading one of the Squirrel Diaries books my daughter wrote and illustrated with the legend “Be a bookworm!” while another shows a peaceful bike ride through the woods with “Take a good book with you everywhere!”) and creations of love. She still writes and draws, but not quite the same way or with the same pure passion to share. Her story isn’t over, but neither of us can fully return to that past.

The result: Picking up a book and either grabbing a bookmark from my stash or opening the book to see the one I left inside stirs all kinds of memories, often briefly, but just as often with great emotion.

Also: I’m getting older, and I appreciate the help.

Not quite a confession

Item: At First Things, George Weigel writes about a certain right-wing* podcaster and her thriving traffic in anti-Semitic conspiracism.

Item: At WSJ Free Expression on Substack, Jack Butler writes about the small but vocal and perverting presence in the Republican Party of the Groypers, who also traffic in anti-Semitism.

My first year teaching, a brand-new adjunct and newly married, I volunteered to emcee the Holocaust Remembrance Day event organized by the Humanities department at the college where I was working. I introduced a panel of History instructors who did a good job providing broad coverage of everything from the Einsatzgruppen (the “Holocaust by bullets”), the Wannsee Conference, and the extermination camps, and a few instructors from other fields covering things like the debt Hitler owed to Nietzsche.

The event was well-attended and informative and—with the exception of the Nietzsche talk, which was confusing even to me and during which I heard a lot of shifting in seats—engrossing and moving. Afterward, I stood talking with two of the senior History instructors. I felt proud to have contributed even a little bit to the event’s success, and was glad to see a lot of my students present for it.

But as we stood talking, a middle-aged man approached us. I don’t remember an introduction or a greeting, though I doubt he would have been rude to us, but I clearly remember his agitated gestures and the way he fought to control the tone of his voice.

“I just have to say, this was very good,” he said, “but you’re treating this all as if it’s ancient history, as if it’s over. I still get hate mail, anonymous letters saying ‘Die, Jew!’”

He talked quite a bit more, but that’s all I remember. One of the other instructors simply nodded along and thanked him for his feedback. I recall the man walking away but, thirteen years later, nothing else from the rest of that night.

I remember it because it was awkward, but also because I struggled with what he said. I was sorry he had had such experiences, and I didn’t doubt that there were still benighted people out there who would give him a hard time because he was Jewish, but I felt our historical presentation had to be just that—historical—and couldn’t address an outlier like one Jewish man living in 2013 frustrated by a handful of racists.

That’s how I thought of it for a long time: an outlier, something that should be avoided. Should be, which implies that it could be.

I’m sure that man would have disagreed. I’ve come to see that I was wrong and he was right.

I learned about the Holocaust at a young age—I recall hearing stories about it from my Mom in second or third grade—and anti-Semitism has never been part of my life. That prejudice simply didn’t exist in my family or church. It was wrong, simpliciter. Anti-Semitism was something Hitler and the Klan did, but Hitler was long dead and the Klan was irrelevant, the one suspected Klansman in our area being a feeble old man more pitied or mocked than feared.

As I got older and developed an interest in conspiracism, I ran into anti-Semitism everywhere. At first it piqued my interest in historiography, Holocaust denial being a historiographic non-starter but an instructive example of bad research and argument. Then I started to realize the Satanic role anti-Semitism played. A conspiracist could be an amusing nutter no matter how many theories they swallowed, but introduce even a hint of anti-Semitism—maybe a little “international bankers” here, a little “Zionist plot” there—and things turned darker and much more obsessive quickly.** The Truther friend urging you to “follow the money trail” during an uncomfortable lunch could be something much more wicked the next time you saw him.

And yet these were still fringe beliefs as far as I was concerned. Weirdos on the internet ranted about them, and half the time it seemed like a joke. But after the last few years, and especially since the perverse response to October 7—which has proven genuinely bipartisan—I have no such illusions. I regret ever thinking even a little bit badly of that man at the Remembrance Day event.

In a short reflection this summer I quoted Walker Percy with regard to the sinking feeling I get when I discover that yet another person I know, have merely met, have interacted with online, or simply observed, is infected with this kind of thing. If it is true—and I strongly suspect it is—that, as Weigel says, anti-Semitism is “always a sure sign of cultural decay,” the frequency with which I am disappointed is more disheartening to me than any electoral outcome or culture war battle or fearmongering headline.

* I try to avoid right-left labels, but I won’t say “conservative” in this case.

** When I did a podcast on Jack Chick with Danny Anderson years ago, the one kudos we could agree to give Chick—the anti-Catholic, anti-Mason, Satanic Panic paranoiac par excellence—was that despite everything he never went down the anti-Semitic rabbit hole.

Rereading and maturity

A few years ago an episode of the late lamented Great Books podcast on For Whom the Bell Tolls convinced me to give Ernest Hemingway another shot someday. Hemingway’s appearance as an important side character in Tim Powers’s latest, The Mills of the Gods, pushed me to start now.

I spent years hating Hemingway, all because of A Farewell to Arms. I read it in high school at the age of sixteen or seventeen, probably because I had discovered All Quiet on the Western Front and wanted another hard-hitting novel about combat. A Farewell to Arms, with its ambulance driver narrator and minimal behind-the-lines action—during a retreat, no less—was not that book. I might have finished the book merely disappointed were it not for the romantic plot between protagonist Frederic Henry and nurse Catherine Barkley.

My seventeen-year old response to Hemingway’s novel was essentially: This idiot gets a woman pregnant, bails on the army, and expects us to feel sorry for him! Everything bad that happens to him is his fault!

The book miffed me so much that for the next twenty-five years the only other Hemingway I read was The Old Man and the Sea, which I liked. But I couldn’t help noticing that a lot of my own favorite writers loved Hemingway and often mentioned how much they had learned from reading and rereading his work. Elmore Leonard was the most important of these; I couldn’t shake off his opinion the way I did the literary critics and lit professors in their modish sinecures.

Now I’m rereading A Farewell to Arms. There are no words to describe how differently it affects me at forty-two.

I missed all the implicit, unstated details that make the story affecting. At seventeen I took Henry and Catherine to be immoral, simpliciter. Now I see that Henry, for all his experience and understanding of the war, is hopelessly naive. He doesn’t understand that his feelings for Catherine are pure childish infatuation. He begs her for sex and doesn’t realize she’s only caving to the continuous pressure he’s putting on her. He doesn’t see that she merely feels sorry for him. His neediness and even his contentment when things go his way are pathetic. Even after she has become pregnant and he feebly tries to plan for the future, she is standoffish and reserves part of herself from him. A telling moment about halfway through:

“Wine is a grand thing,” I said. “It makes you forget all the bad.”
“It’s lovely,” said Catherine. “But it’s given my father gout very badly.”
“Have you a father?”
“Yes,” said Catherine. “He has gout. You won’t ever have to meet him.”

Henry hasn’t even bothered to find out about Catherine’s family up to this point and he misses entirely the import of “You won’t ever have to meet him.” Catherine sees no future in this. Whether she has plans for later or simply feels trapped, she’s waiting him out.

Every other character sees these things but Henry. Most importantly, the novel does, too. A Farewell to Arms is narrated by an older Henry with a decade or more of perspective on these events. (Reading the baseball news in the hospital he notes for the reader of 1929: “Babe Ruth was a pitcher then playing for Boston.”) The novel’s profound pathos is rooted in irony. The reader, through the old Henry’s more mature narration, sees what Henry doesn’t: his situation, the problems he’s creating with Catherine, how she actually feels about him despite his fervent crush.

Henry is whining about problems he caused himself? That’s the point. Benefit of hindsight. He makes terrible choices, but unlike at seventeen, I sympathize, because I can recognize the foolishness that the young Henry can’t. Anyone who has ever remembered youthful sin and bad choices—especially in a doomed or one-sided relationship—has felt the same pang. A Farewell to Arms evokes it with agonizing truthfulness. This is what I was too immature to detect in high school.

A few years ago when I read The Great Gatsby for the first time I wondered why it was ever assigned to high schoolers. What could a fifteen- or sixteen-year old hope to get out of a book, as I put it later, “of hidden pasts, severed roots, lust, and mountains of regret,” that “depends for its resonance on similarly long, difficult experience”? They are likely not mature enough to get what Fitzgerald is doing. Worse, reading it for symbolism and technique when you’re not ready for the story will flatten and cheapen it if it doesn’t ruin it altogether.

A Farewell to Arms offers precisely that example in my own life. It makes much clearer to me now the role of maturity not only in understanding but in responding rightly to a great novel.

If I’m celebrating people publicly changing their minds this week, I’m glad to admit I was wrong about the novel and Hemingway. I regret that it took me so long to come back to A Farewell to Arms, but I’m glad that I’ve read it now in a time and place where I can get what Hemingway was doing. It’s subtle, understated, and that much more powerfully moving, and even though I know what tragedy is approaching Henry and Catherine, I can’t wait to finish it.

Thunderstruck

I’ve written about my maternal grandfather here many times before. A year or so ago I learned something surprising about him: he was terrified of thunderstorms.

The house he raised my mom and her siblings in and in which I spent many happy days of my childhood sat on a hilltop. Three enormous oaks stood around the driveway. One by one over the years the lightning took them. One I can only remember as a stump, right from the beginning of my own awareness. Another I remember faintly, as both a living tree and as a shattered obstacle and tangle of limbs to be removed. The last, in which he hung a rope swing for us, lasted until I was an adult, but now it too is gone.

Maybe that had something to do with it—living in a lightning rod. It occurred to me recently that he also used the very top of the hill as a scrapyard for his plumbing-electric business. Coils of copper wire and stacks of copper pipe lay there, inviting the storm.

What most surprised me about this fear was his response. Apparently when my mom and her siblings were kids, if a thunderstorm rolled in over the northeast Georgia mountains he would load the entire family into the car and drive around until it had dissipated. He didn’t want simply to get away from the house, but to keep moving and stay busy during the entire storm.

“I don’t know what happened to him to make him like that,” my mom has said.

This is the man who inspired the grandfather in Griswoldville, who worked for decades in a business that exposed him to electrocution and sewage and crooked contractors, who told me stories about watching the flash of artillery over the next ridge in Korea, who grew up in poverty with no indoor plumbing. Imagining him frightened, and so frightened that he chose flight, was a revelation. I’ve been thinking about it a lot, especially when my turn now comes for thunderstorms to roll in over the South Carolina upstate. I may not react the way he did, but I understand the fear.

A curious change: as a kid I didn’t mind the thunder. When I was small we replaced our shingle roof with metal and I learned to love the sound of rain on it. (If I could find a white noise app that combined heavy rain on a metal roof and the rushing mountain creek about fifty feet from my bedroom window, and if the storm could gradually fade into the sounds of crickets and tree frogs, I’d never struggle to sleep again.) The occasional thunder was rarely sharp or loud enough to be frightening, and when it was my parents taught me to regard it as a demonstration of God’s power. Look at what his creation can do! As a result, for many years I saw thunder as just that—a novelty if not an inconvenience, an instructive change in the weather that usually passed quickly.

But somewhere in the last few years my granddad’s terror has sprouted up in me. It’s not fear, precisely, but a gnawing worry. I can feel it in my chest. When the sky dims and clouds—as it did earlier this week, as it is today, as I write this—something clenches and won’t release, not until the storm is over. Until then, I fret over wind and leaks (our roof hasn’t leaked once and there is no sign that it will) and tornadoes (a real but much more remote threat).

Frontline troops in the First World War sometimes described waiting out a barrage in terms like “weathering a storm.” The strain broke some men. Passive sitting, waiting for destruction that may or may not come, confronts one with smallness and a total lack of control. Waiting out a thunderstorm is usually not nearly as serious, but that feeling is recognizable. Better, since one has the option unlike the men on the Western Front, to do something—even just drive around—than sit still and take it.

What happened to my granddad to give him that fear? Maybe something as a kid, which is what the question suggests. Then again, people aren’t that simple, so maybe nothing. But if this was not a lifelong fear, as in my case, where it’s only cropped up in the last several years, I suspect responsibility played a role. As a kid I enjoyed the thunder because of the blessing of being taken care of, rather than taking care of others. I only fret about these things now because of the good things in life—a house, my wife, our kids. I don’t want to worry away my forties and the kids’ childhoods in fear.

I have to wonder whether my granddad’s destinationless thunderstorm car rides stopped once my mom and aunt and uncle were older. I remember my granddad as unflappable. He was a man of integrity and duty and I wish I could ask whether he learned to take captive his fear and, if so, how.

Perhaps someday, when it will all seem so eternally distant that we can both laugh about it. Until then, with each storm and downpour, I pray to think of blessing rather than danger, and to control my worry, actively and purposefully, with love.

Something special and small

I mentioned last month that I’ve been doing a leisurely reread of Chesterton’s Orthodoxy. I finished it last night which, being Maundy Thursday, the evening before Good Friday, turned out to be perfect timing.

I did a blog event I called Chestertober a couple years ago but wasn’t able to follow it up last fall. I’m considering reviving it this year. If I can manage it, Orthodoxy will be one of the major books I mean to review. It was my introduction to Chesterton twenty years ago—I recall reading it during the summer of what must have been 2006—and proved genuinely revelatory. It’s frequently quoted for a reason. I could pull out a dozen passages per chapter, minimum, and comment on them at length and still find more to consider and work through on another reading.

For now, as part of observing and thinking about Good Friday, here are two that leapt out at me in the final chapter last night.

First, near the end, as Chesterton ties together the book’s arguments, he narrows his focus briefly from broad philosophical and cultural conflicts to the mischaracterization of Christianity as “something weak and diseased” and the character of Christ himself, who has often been portrayed as “a gentle creature, sheepish and unworldly”:

“The diction used about Christ has been, and perhaps wisely, sweet and submissive. But the diction used by Christ is quite curiously gigantesque”

Instead of looking at books and pictures about the New Testament I looked at the New Testament. There I found an account, not in the least of a person with his hair parted in the middle or his hands clasped in appeal, but of an extraordinary being with lips of thunder and acts of lurid decision, flinging down tables, casting out devils, passing with the wild secrecy of the wind from mountain isolation to a sort of dreadful demagogy; a being who often acted like an angry god—and always like a god. . . . The diction used about Christ has been, and perhaps wisely, sweet and submissive. But the diction used by Christ is quite curiously gigantesque; it is full of camels leaping through needles and mountains hurled into the sea. Morally it is equally terrific; he called himself a sword of slaughter, and told men to buy swords if they sold their coats for them. That he used other even wilder words on the side of non-resistance greatly increases the mystery; but it also, if anything, rather increases the violence.

A brilliantly concise summary of the moralistic “be nice” Jesus manufactured out of a variety of ulterior motives and the man we actually encounter in the Gospels. The contrast is perhaps most striking if one returns to the Gospels after several years, or reads them straight through in a reader’s Bible—a topic I intend to write about one of these days—rather than parceling them out in discrete episodes or tidied up storybook versions. And the “extraordinary” quality of Christ is nowhere more apparent than in the events of Holy Week.

Second, and most personally moving to me, was the book’s penultimate paragraph. Having considered the way paganism, for all its strengths and admirable qualities, still left men in despair, the state to which Christianity’s critics threaten to return the world, Chesterton closes Orthodoxy with his most important point:

The mass of men have been forced to be gay about the little things, but sad about the big ones. Nevertheless (I offer my last dogma defiantly) it is not native to man to be so. Man is more himself, man is more manlike, when joy is the fundamental thing in him, and grief the superficial. Melancholy should be an innocent interlude, a tender and fugitive frame of mind; praise should be the permanent pulsation of the soul. Pessimism is at best an emotional half-holiday; joy is the uproarious labour by which all things live. Yet, according to the apparent estate of man as seen by the pagan or the agnostic, this primary need of human nature can never be fulfilled. Joy ought to be expansive; but for the agnostic it must be contracted, it must cling to one corner of the world. Grief ought to be a concentration; but for the agnostic its desolation is spread through an unthinkable eternity. . . . Christianity satisfies suddenly and perfectly man's ancestral instinct for being the right way up; satisfies it supremely in this; that by its creed joy becomes something gigantic and sadness something special and small.

I did not recall this passage from previous readings; it had not stuck out to me or stuck with me. That changed this time.

“Man is more himself, man is more manlike, when joy is the fundamental thing in him, and grief the superficial.”

I’ve mentioned before the struggle that this winter and spring have been, of the insomnia and depression and paranoia and exhaustion. The melancholy of January grew so deep during our back-to-back weekends of ice and snow that I picked up Orthodoxy precisely because of its early passages on madness. Chesterton has a reputation for rescuing diseased minds from the brink and, though whatever I was going through wasn’t that severe, I reckoned I needed it. And it worked.

But to begin with madness—reaching for an old favorite as a comfort at a time when I felt like I was losing my mind—and to end with the above passage… that felt truly providential. Reading last night, I recognized myself from two months ago. Grief, melancholy, pessimism—these are my natural bent anyway but had somehow become “the fundamental thing.” Something had gone badly wrong. But far from mere description, this passage is also prescriptive. It can feel like this state lasts forever, but thanks to Christ these will only be temporary.

Already they have been lifting. Good Friday is a chance to remember that they will, if not now, be lifted forever. They’ve already been conquered, reduced to “something special and small.”

I hope this is an encouragement to y’all as it has been to me. If you haven’t read Orthodoxy, do so. I first picked it up because I had learned, somewhere, somehow, of Chesterton’s influence on CS Lewis. But I’ve read and reread it over the years on its own merits. Every time I enjoy my favorite parts again, and every time some part I had never noticed before touches something in me that I never knew needed help.

I shall not reply

In the summer of 1859, the New-York Tribune accused Robert E Lee of having three of his late father-in-law’s slaves, who had run away about a month before, caught and whipped, with Lee personally whipping a woman when the man administering the beating refused to. Horace Greeley’s Tribune was an anti-slavery paper and the accusation was made in an anonymous letter by a writer clearly unfamiliar with the provisions of Lee’s father-in-law’s will—of which Lee was the executor—and ended with a pointed political message. It was propaganda calculated to invite outrage—and provoke a response.

Lee’s only statement on the matter came in a letter to one of his sons: “The N.Y. Tribune has attacked me for my treatment of your grandfather’s slaves, but I shall not reply.”

One of the most annoying and unseemly aspects of online and social media culture is the endless calling-out of haters. Public figures of whatever level of fame, influence, and authority inevitably end up spotlighting and condemning their critics, which prompts fans to voice their support and dog-pile the enemy.

I’ve unfollowed a number of writers and thinkers I otherwise like precisely because of this. One popular evangelical literary scholar eventually made her presence on Instagram entirely about screenshotting hate mail and sharing it with a dismissive, above-it-all caption. An up-and-coming novelist on Substack has recently lashed out at a few people poking fun at her pretentions in a long essay describing them as anti-intellectuals and misogynists. I could multiply examples. The comments on these posts are always full of praise and affirmation, which is surely part of the point. It betrays a neediness and fragility I find not merely off-putting but embarrassing.

The technology doesn’t help, of course. The perverse incentives of social media demand response, immediately, and the knowledge that the fans will have your back against the haters only intensifies the pull toward the reply button. A mob can make anything feel righteous. Then follows the well-known dopamine rush of the zinger. And once the habit is formed, there’s no going back. You’ve fed the trolls. You’re ensnared, no better than the haters, slinging mud in the notes or reels or comments and basking in the praise of your yes-men. It’s this scene from “Community” all day, every day.

What I would like to see much, much more of is detachment. I shall not reply. Rather than acting like you’re above it all, rather than saying the criticism doesn’t matter, why not be above it all by ignoring it, not even mentioning it? Answer not a fool. That might mean letting the opinions of idiots stand but it wouldn’t degrade your own character. But as was clear even 2,000 years ago, most people would rather seem than be.

Lee understood this even in the newspaper era. There is some criticism not worth responding to, to which responding would only validate and encourage your critics by lowering yourself to their level. What must it have taken a man like him, of his background and character, facing such an accusation in such a difficult personal situation, not to reply? Discipline, for one thing, which the technology actively works to erode. He had avoided entanglement in journalistic controversies before and that habit didn’t fail him now. I doubt many of us could have made the same choice in 1859. I know even fewer could now.

2026 Local Author Expo recap

My table Saturday, with a cameo by the top of my son George’s head

The Greenville Library’s annual Local Author Expo took place this past Saturday. This was my first expo in a few years, and I was grateful to participate again.

The Library hosted us at the Hughes Main Library downtown. They did a good job of including a wide variety of work, including fantasy, mystery, children’s fiction, picture books, poetry, and non-fiction. Nearby were my friends Dana Caldwell, whose The Twelve Kingdoms, the first volume of an epic fantasy trilogy, my daughter is currently eating up, and Paul Michael Garrison, author of a pair of crime mysteries: Letters to the Editor and The Lies People Publish. I enjoyed catching up (and commiserating) with them.

The doors opened at 10:00 and once foot traffic picked up around 10:30 or 10:45 it stayed pretty busy, with plenty of people coming and going. I was surprised and pleased to meet a Substack follower who dropped by my table with his twin daughters. We talked about my books and the intertwined joys and travails of twin fatherhood, which was fun and gratifying. I also got to meet many strangers with a huge variety of backgrounds and interests—a retired cop who bought The Snipers and Dark Full of Enemies, a former Civil War reenactor whose second love is the Vikings, leader her to buy No Snakes in Iceland—and the friendliness of the crowd was as much of an encouragement as the sales I made.

Seeing and talking to readers in the flesh is also a good reminder that we’re made to enjoy each other’s company in real life. I spoke to a number of people who, to judge by the slogans on their shirts or the things they said, have opposed or simply quite different worldviews and opinions from me, but talking over a table of books was an opportunity to enjoy real community, united by courtesy and a shared love of stories. I’d certainly like more of that and less of the online hubbub. It’s a place to start, at least.

A great event, and I’d like to thank my three eldest, who helped me out at my table all three hours. They were not only a big help to me—putting cards and bookmarks inside each book sold, engaging the folks who stopped by with questions, and, in Sophie’s case, even stumping for her favorites of my stories—but it was fun to see them enjoy themselves at the tables of other authors.

They were especially taken with Emily Golus’s World of Vindor series and Sarah Dean’s Midnight Post and the Postbox Clock. I wasn’t able to stop by their tables during the expo, but the kids loved visiting with them. My parents also attended and my mom picked up a couple picture books for our younger kids: Finicky Frances, by Krista Leann, a book about picky eaters (a subject my mom knows all too well) and Adelina Aviator, by Jessica Vana (with nice illustrations by former Disney designer Adam Dix), about a girl who becomes a missionary pilot. Give all of their books a look.

This was a great event and I look forward to participating again—I hope with another book available! I spent much of my spring break last week starting a harsh final read-through of my manuscript for The Wanderer. Stay tuned for more, and I hope to see y’all there next year.

A really solid Tennessee excursion

Chickamauga: Cannon and monuments at the site of the Confederate breakthrough

Pardon the title. The kids put on Glenn Miller this morning during breakfast and I have “Chattanooga Choo-Choo” stuck in my head. That’s appropriate, though, because I’d already been planning to write about what we were doing five years ago right now: visiting Chattanooga. I wrote a review of one of the places we visited at the time: The National Medal of Honor Heritage Center, which is right next door to the Tennessee Aquarium. The kids greatly enjoyed both. I notice now that I had promised to write more about my highlight of the trip later.

I suppose five years to the day is “later.” The highlight was a tour of the battlefield at Chickamauga.

The second bloodiest battle of the Civil War and the second bloodiest battle ever fought in north American occurred in September 1863 on the Georgia side of the state line just south of Chattanooga, part of the broader Union campaign to capture that city preparatory to invading Georgia and capturing the railroad hub at Atlanta. The battle began as a piecemeal, raggedy fight through dense forest along a broad front with a ridge at the Union’s back. The arrival of greater and greater numbers on both sides gradually allowed the battle to coalesce into a massive contest of frontal assaults.

The most dramatic moment of the battle came on the second day, when General James Longstreet hit a massive gap that had opened in the Union center with a sledgehammer blow of 10,000 men attacking in column. Eyewitnesses to the assault, who later described the massed Confederate troops pouring into the open fields of the Brotherton farm under streaming battle flags, were staggered by the sight. The attack broke the Union army, which fell back into the foothills and fought a series of heroic delaying actions as the army began its retreat to Chattanooga.

It was a massive victory for the Confederacy. The Confederate commander, the prickly, inscrutable Braxton Bragg, had a momentary lift in his reputation. The Union commander, William Rosecrans, whose confused orders resulted in the gap that Longstreet had blown apart, ended up resigning. His military career was over.

The losses were also massive. Four generals were killed, including Benjamin Hardin Helm, Mary Todd Lincoln’s brother-in-law. The Lincoln White House went into quiet, unpublicized mourning. And thousands of ordinary soldiers were killed and wounded—the casualties were second only to Gettysburg in the whole war and the heaviest by far in all of the Western Theatre—including someone whose last words I’ve written about here before: South Carolina Sergeant Richard Rowland Kirkland, “the Angel of Marye’s Heights.”

It’s a huge, important, fascinating battle that is often overshadowed by Eastern Theatre battles like Gettysburg and Antietam or Union victories in the West like Vicksburg or Atlanta. For more, here’s a good short guide and an excellent animated map from American Battlefield Trust. For a book-length treatment, I’d recommend Peter Cozzens’s This Terrible Sound: The Battle of Chickamauga, which I read ahead of our visit.

The battle itself is significant and interesting, but visiting the battlefield meant much, much more to me.

The Civil War was the first historical event or period that I developed a serious interest in, somewhere about third or fourth grade. By fifth grade it obsessed me. I read everything I could get my hands on—fiction and non-fiction, Rifles for Watie and The Boys’ War among many others—and borrowed every Civil War documentary available at the Rabun County Library. For years I got multiple Civil War coffee table books and atlases for Christmas.

But growing up in northeast Georgia did not leave me a lot of options for seeing places from the Civil War. We only visited Atlanta by necessity and its battlefield has been buried under urban sprawl for decades. I did get to visit the Atlanta Cyclorama in its original location by the zoo—I could barely contain myself—but found it disheartening when the guide pointed out that the road running through the middle of the action is now Jimmy Carter Boulevard. (It occurs to me that this must be one of the roots of my interest in historic preservation.)

I learned of the Battle of Griswoldville from one of my library books, but I had no idea where that was and it was a pitiful Confederate defeat to boot. The seeds planted there would take twenty-odd years to sprout. But there was one other option in Georgia, a big one, that I knew about from our encyclopedias: Chickamauga.

The Battle of Chickamauga was big, it was a smashing Confederate victory, and it was fought in north Georgia! I begged to go, for a chance to see a real battlefield.

The problem is that “north Georgia” is a big place and, living in the mountains, it is not fast or easy to travel east-west. The few times I had been out that way—to Space Camp with my dad, or on church trips to camp—we had actually looped up into Tennessee to get to our destination. Places like Rome, Cartersville, or Chickamauga might as well have been on the moon. I don’t remember any specific answers I got from my questions about seeing Chickamauga, but the sense I remember is “We’ll see.” Meaning not for a long time, if ever.

But one person did promise me a visit: my granddad.

He was someone I could always talk to about my Civil War obsession. I barely remember any of those conversations, but I vividly recall him promising to take me to Chickamauga someday. The memory is still vivid because I could imagine the trip in one of his old trucks—the feel and smell of the seats, the road noise, the gas station snacks we’d certainly pick up (circus peanuts for him, Lance Gold-n-Chees for me), the talk with him we’d enjoy on the long drive.

We never got to make that trip, though. About that time, as I wrapped up elementary school and entered middle school, he was diagnosed with melanoma. He held on for a good while but, after Christmas 1997, declined quickly. He died March 13, 1998. 28 years ago today.

And five years ago today, on the 23rd anniversary of his death, I got to visit Chickamauga. I didn’t get to see the battlefield with him, but I did take my wife and three oldest kids, the dearest people in the world to me and the people I would most have liked him to meet. My oldest son, who was three and a half, at the time, is named after him.

That trip to Chattanooga, with its loop down to Chickamauga and Rock City—more on that in another five years, maybe—was a good trip all-around, but the best moment came there on the battlefield. We stopped the car to see the monument to my homestate. Georgia monuments on a lot of Eastern Theatre battlefields are pretty modest, usually a square granite column with the state seal. The one at Chickamauga, though, is a monument—almost ninety feet tall, surmounted by a bronze flagbearer and with lower pedestals commemorating Georgia’s infantry, cavalry, and artillerymen. It’s beautiful.

We got out of the car and the kids, with no idea yet of how much this visit, here, with them, meant to me, charged across the field to get a closer look. As I followed with Sarah and our youngest, my heart swelled, and I said a prayer of thanks: for them, for my homestate, that we could make this trip, and most of all for my granddad.

23 years is a long time, but it was worth the wait.

In dreams

I’ve taken on a somewhat wistful tone since the beginning of the year, at least partly because of feeling exhausted and downcast. Mercifully, I have improved a lot over the last few weeks—especially with regard to being able to sleep—but there’s still a good way to go. Being able to write again has helped. So has improved sleep. With that in mind, here’s a dream I had two nights ago:

After several odd dreams—including trying to liberate British POWs from a Japanese rowboat, something almost stereotypically predictable—my middle son, who is almost seven, and I stepped out of those dreamscapes onto a broad carpeted staircase on a completely imaginary campus of my college. At the top we walked into a large conference hall filled with tables, all crowded with school leadership. In the middle of the room, very close to us where we stood near the door, was my late grandmother, enthusiastically presenting a proposal for a new arts program.

My grandmother was a talented and prolific artist and so this was unsurprising. What I did note was that she looked much younger, probably around the age she was when I was born. What did not cross my mind at all in the dream was that she is no longer alive. (Knowing this within the dream has made it hard to talk to or interact with other relatives in other dreams.)

My son (named after her) and I just stood and listened. I appreciated how eloquently she was speaking to the movers and shakers at my school and was hopeful for the program she was describing.

And that was it. I woke up.

What’s curious about this dream is that, rather than deepening my sense of loss or sickheartedness, seeing my grandmother was a comfort. Purely and simply.

As I’ve written before, I dream a lot—what feels like all night, every night. (This has been a helpful measure of how much better I’m feeling; a month ago my dreams were completely jumbled fragments. Now they at least cohere into nonsense.) I’ve incorporated this into my fiction; I wouldn’t know how to understand my characters otherwise. Georgie Wax in particular—who, like my son, is also named for my grandmother—has the same sorts of dreams I do in Griswoldville, and in the end gets the same comfort from some of them. “O, what a foretaste,” he writes near the end.

I don’t know what such dreams mean, if anything—though I would like to think, as Georgie Wax does, that they are a booster shot of hope for the resurrection—but I am grateful for them when they come along.