Yankee nitpickers and cucumber patches
/The extent to which the Connecticut-born Cormac McCarthy could be considered a Southerner or the author of Southern literature has been an open question to me. He was born in Connecticut and moved south as a small child, when his lawyer father got to work for the Roosevelt administration uprooting farmers from valleys slated for flooding by the TVA, but began his career with novels about east Tennessee mountain outcasts written in a strongly Faulknerian style.
Where you’re from matters, and I tend to be an inveterate skeptic of outsiders moving into a place and then claiming it for themselves, but I do believe it’s possible to adopt a new place as your home. That takes more than a simple change of location, though. An embrace and, at best, a seamless, unconscious absorption into your new home’s mindset is key.
Cormac McCarthy: A Legacy Revisited, finally gave me an answer to the specific question of McCarthy’s southernness. Toward the middle of the book, he quotes a 1981 letter from McCarthy complaining about the coverage of a mistaken shooting by El Paso police. An excerpt from the full letter:
[T]he kind of nitpicking criticism it received in the yankitized press is just what we down here dont need. Sure, the guy made a mistake. What the yankee press failed to mention—in every account—was that he said he was sorry. . . . Anyway, we sure as hell dont need a bunch of damn Yankee nitpickers jumping up & down & chortling over what they see as “decadence” of the old southwest. As far as I am concerned those folks had better see to their own cucumber patch.
Daugherty quotes pieces of the letter as evidence of the extent to which McCarthy, in middle age, had already come to identify with the Southwest, but this is a recognizably Southern attitude. (And, in an even more intense form, Appalachian, mountain people of all continents being standoffish and suspicious of outsiders.) I think some version of this almost every day. The best interpretation of the Battle Flag in its modern usage is nothing more specific than “Mind your own business.”
In the next letter to his correspondent, McCarthy apologizes for “the motel incident business” and writes that “my letter was meant as a joke.” It’s unclear which part he means. But given the rarity with which he answered letters at the time and that the entire letter was devoted to his rant (“Anyway, I’m glad to get this off of my chest. It needed to be said & I’ve said it”) one suspects he means his perspective on the details of the incident and not the overall sentiment.
A Legacy Revisited has a lot of information about McCarthy’s life that gives me pause—not that I wasn’t prepared for that—but, reading this passage, I felt like we were, for one moment separated by forty-five years, resonating on precisely the same frequency. It’s the most heartwarming thing McCarthy ever wrote.